inthesingularity.ai
Wire · Export controls · Bitdeer

W.132Lutnick backed a seven-country chip rule that could spare a Bitdeer site, NYT summaries say

The New York Times reported on November 15 that Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has pushed a narrower rule on AI chips in overseas data centers: seven countries, future shipments only, and notification in place of an automatic licence. Other officials want it to apply worldwide. By AI Weekly’s account the narrower version would spare a 21.7 MW site Bitdeer is building in Johor, Malaysia, for which Bitdeer reports more than $1.7B of expected revenue over five years. Cantor Fitzgerald, run by Lutnick’s sons, is one of 12 sales agents on Bitdeer’s $1B share programme. The Times found no evidence that this influenced him, the summaries say.

Countries in the narrower rule, as reported
7
Bitdeer has sites in two, Malaysia and Norway: 473.5 MW, 15.2% of its table
A201, Johor Bahru
21.7 MW
more than $1.7B of expected revenue over five years; target Q2 2027
Bitdeer’s Malaysian sites
225.8 MW
six sites, all AI cloud; 2.5 MW online
Share programme Cantor is an agent on
$1.0B
one of 12 agents; about $8.4M sold under it by September 29

What was reported

The rule is not issued, and two versions are being argued over. We could not open the Times article and rely on five summaries of it, which do not contradict each other on the points here; where a point rests on one, we say so. The Commerce Department’s version would cover data centers in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, Brazil, South Africa and Norway. It would apply only to future chip shipments, so sites already stocked with US hardware would be exempt, and it would require companies to notify the government when Chinese customers train AI models there, where the alternative is an automatic licence requirement. Two summaries add that Commerce’s version would apply only above a higher computing-power threshold; none gives a number. Other administration officials want the rule to apply worldwide.

The site the summaries single out is Bitdeer’s A201. By their account the Times reported that the Singapore-based company’s data center in southern Malaysia is set to open next year with hundreds of millions of dollars of Nvidia servers, and that it is expected to serve Tencent. The Tencent point rests on one person with knowledge of the matter; ShiftDelete’s summary says “likely”, and Bitdeer does not name its customers. That the site would be spared is AI Weekly’s description. Malaysia is on the list, so A201 would escape only through the exemption for sites already stocked, and the summaries do not say whether its servers have been delivered.

The link to Lutnick is Cantor Fitzgerald, which he led and his sons now run. The summaries say Cantor was a designated sales agent on a Bitdeer share offering of up to $1B this year, was involved in one of up to $250M in 2024, and holds a Bitdeer stake indirectly through its investment in Tether. They also say the Times found no evidence that Cantor’s interests influenced Lutnick, and, in ShiftDelete’s summary alone, that it described the deals as a tiny part of Cantor’s business and noted that other banks have similar ties. A Commerce spokeswoman said he makes decisions in the best interests of the United States and has complied with his ethics agreements. Cantor declined to comment and Bitdeer did not reply, ShiftDelete’s summary says.

The report landed in a dispute between departments. Bloomberg reported the same day that Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent asked Nvidia’s board to answer within 10 days on its China sales, and that he said four departments had backed blacklisting Megaspeed, a Singapore-based data-center firm, while Commerce blocked it. That account is from AI Weekly’s summary.

Two of the seven countries hold 15% of Bitdeer’s capacity table; only 86.5 MW of that is online

Bitdeer’s data center capacity by country, megawatts, from the table in its third-quarter release, as of October 31, 2026. Solid: sites the table marks as online. Outlined: sites with a later target date, including the pipeline. Pink: countries among the seven the narrower rule would cover, as the Times’s report was summarised. Most of Bitdeer’s capacity is for Bitcoin mining; AI sites are stated in megawatts of IT load, so the rows mix two measures as the company’s own total does.

In the seven, onlineIn the seven, plannedElsewhere, onlineElsewhere, planned
05001,0001,5002,000United StatesUnited States: 784 MW onlineUnited States: 1,112.5 MW not yet online1,896.5 MW · 784 onlineBhutanBhutan: 600 MW online600 MW · 600 onlineNorwayone of the seven countriesNorway: 84 MW onlineNorway: 163.7 MW not yet online247.7 MW · 84 onlineMalaysiaone of the seven countriesMalaysia: 2.5 MW onlineMalaysia: 223.3 MW not yet online225.8 MW · 2.5 onlineCanadaCanada: 101 MW not yet online101 MW · 0 onlineEthiopiaEthiopia: 50 MW online50 MW · 50 online
01,0002,000United StatesUnited States: 784 MW onlineUnited States: 1,112.5 MW not yet online1,896.5 MWBhutanBhutan: 600 MW online600 MWNorwayin the sevenNorway: 84 MW onlineNorway: 163.7 MW not yet online247.7 MWMalaysiain the sevenMalaysia: 2.5 MW onlineMalaysia: 223.3 MW not yet online225.8 MWCanadaCanada: 101 MW not yet online101 MWEthiopiaEthiopia: 50 MW online50 MW
All 21 rows of the table
SiteCountryMWStatusUse
Rockdale, TexasUnited States563OnlineCrypto / colocation / AI Cloud
JigmelingBhutan500OnlineCrypto
Massillon, OhioUnited States221OnlineCrypto
GeduBhutan100OnlineCrypto
MoldeNorway84OnlineCrypto
Tydal, phase 1Norway60.5Q4 2026Colocation
Tydal, phase 2Norway60.5Q1 2027Colocation
Knoxville, TennesseeUnited States55Q4 2027Crypto to AI Cloud
OromiaEthiopia50OnlineCrypto
Tydal, phase 3Norway42.7H2 2027Colocation / AI Cloud
Wenatchee, WashingtonUnited States8.5H2 2028Crypto to AI Cloud
A101, CyberjayaMalaysia2.5OnlineAI Cloud
Clarington, OhioUnited States570to be updatedTo be updated
Weathersfield, OhioUnited States300Q4 2028Colocation / AI Cloud
Rockdale, Texas (expansion)United States179Q4 2026, phasedCrypto / colocation / AI Cloud
Fox Creek, AlbertaCanada101Q4 2027Crypto
A901Malaysia67Q2 2027AI Cloud
A202, JohorMalaysia65.1Q3 2027AI Cloud
A103Malaysia60Q1 2028AI Cloud
A201, Johor BahruMalaysia21.7Q2 2027AI Cloud
A102, CyberjayaMalaysia9.5Q1 2027AI Cloud
Total3,121.01,520.5 online

What Bitdeer’s filings say about the site

A201 is small in megawatts and large in expected revenue. Bitdeer announced it on September 29: about 21.7 MW in Johor Bahru, liquid-cooled and built for Nvidia’s GB300 racks, with off-take commitments for more than 70% of capacity. Its third-quarter release puts that at more than $1.7B of expected revenue over five years. That is the company’s expectation under commitments covering part of the site, not contracted revenue for all of it. Bitdeer said it had bought more than 100 GB300 racks ahead of energisation and did not disclose customers.

On a simple average that is more than $340M a year, about four times the annual recurring revenue of the company’s whole AI cloud business. Bitdeer’s AI cloud revenue was $20.4M in the third quarter, 6.4% of its $320.7M of revenue, and it reported annual recurring revenue of about $86M in September. A201’s five-year figure is 59% of the roughly $2.9B AI cloud backlog it reported at September 30, which had been $0.9B in August.

Bitdeer’s documents give different dates for different milestones. The September announcement gave energisation in the first quarter of 2027; the October update gave January for readiness and April for go-live; the capacity table in the November release says the second quarter. All fit “next year”.

A201 is one of six Malaysian sites. The table lists 225.8 MW in Malaysia, every site for AI cloud, of which 2.5 MW is online. A201 and its neighbour A202 in Johor come to 86.8 MW. A102 in Cyberjaya, at 9.5 MW, is fully contracted for five years with more than $800M of expected revenue. The summaries do not say whether the Times discussed the other five.

A201 is the fourth-largest of Bitdeer’s six Malaysian sites; 2.5 of 225.8 MW is online

Bitdeer’s sites in Malaysia, megawatts of IT load, with the target dates in its capacity table as of October 31, 2026. Strong grey: online. Pink: A201, the site in the Times’s report. Faint grey: the other planned sites. Contract notes are Bitdeer’s descriptions; it does not name customers.

020406080A901target Q2 2027A901: 67 MW, target Q2 2027; services agreement signed67 MW · services agreement signedA202, Johortarget Q3 2027A202, Johor: 65.1 MW, target Q3 2027; 10-year agreement65.1 MW · 10-year agreementA103target Q1 2028A103: 60 MW, target Q1 202860 MWA201, Johor Bahrutarget Q2 2027A201, Johor Bahru: 21.7 MW, target Q2 2027; over 70% off-take21.7 MW · over 70% off-takeA102, Cyberjayatarget Q1 2027A102, Cyberjaya: 9.5 MW, target Q1 2027; 100% contracted, five years9.5 MW · 100% contracted, five yearsA101, CyberjayaonlineA101, Cyberjaya: 2.5 MW, online2.5 MW
020406080A901Q2 2027A901: 67 MW, target Q2 2027; services agreement signed67 MWA202Q3 2027A202, Johor: 65.1 MW, target Q3 2027; 10-year agreement65.1 MWA103Q1 2028A103: 60 MW, target Q1 202860 MWA201Q2 2027A201, Johor Bahru: 21.7 MW, target Q2 2027; over 70% off-take21.7 MWA102Q1 2027A102, Cyberjaya: 9.5 MW, target Q1 2027; 100% contracted, five years9.5 MWA101onlineA101, Cyberjaya: 2.5 MW, online2.5 MW

A201’s expected revenue averages more than $340M a year; Bitdeer’s AI cloud runs at about $86M

$ millions a year. Strong grey: Bitdeer’s AI cloud revenue in the quarter to September 30, 2026, multiplied by four, and the annual recurring revenue in its September update. Faint grey and pink: the expected revenue Bitdeer has stated for two Malaysian sites, each “more than” and over five years, divided by five. The division is ours; Bitdeer gives no yearly profile, and revenue would not start until the sites open in 2027.

0$100M$200M$300M$400MToday, all AI cloudQ3 2026 AI cloud revenue × 4$20.4M in the quarterAI cloud revenue, quarter to September 30, 2026: $20.4M; times four: $81.6M$82MAnnual recurring revenueSeptember 2026 updateAI cloud annual recurring revenue, September 2026 update: about $86M≈$86MExpected revenue, five-year figure ÷ 5A102, Cyberjaya, 9.5 MWmore than $800M over five yearsA102: more than $800M of expected revenue over five years; ÷ 5 = more than $160M a year>$160MA201, Johor Bahru, 21.7 MWmore than $1.7B over five yearsA201: more than $1.7B of expected revenue over five years; ÷ 5 = more than $340M a year>$340M
0$200M$400MTodayQ3 revenue × 4AI cloudAI cloud revenue, quarter to September 30, 2026: $20.4M; times four: $81.6M$82MARR, SeptemberAI cloudAI cloud annual recurring revenue, September 2026 update: about $86M≈$86MExpected, per yearA102, 9.5 MW>$800M ÷ 5A102: more than $800M of expected revenue over five years; ÷ 5 = more than $160M a year>$160MA201, 21.7 MW>$1.7B ÷ 5A201: more than $1.7B of expected revenue over five years; ÷ 5 = more than $340M a year>$340M

What the filings say about Cantor’s role

Cantor is one of 12 sales agents on the $1B programme. Bitdeer’s prospectus supplement of August 10 covers at-the-market sales of Class A shares up to $1,000,000,000 and names 12 agents, Barclays and Cantor Fitzgerald & Co. first among them. Commission is up to 3.0% of gross sales, which would be at most $30M for all agents together if every dollar were sold.

Little of it had been sold by late September. Bitdeer reported about $8.4M of net proceeds under the new supplement as of September 29, and $58.0M of at-the-market proceeds in the third quarter. It had raised $491.9M that way in the first half under earlier supplements. The shares closed at $5.60 on November 13, 49% below the $10.88 in the supplement. At that price the full $1B would be about 179M shares, 65% of those outstanding, and 65% of a market value of about $1.55B.

The 2024 agreement had 6 agents. The sales agreement of March 18, 2024 lists B. Riley, Cantor, Needham, StockBlock, Roth and Rosenblatt. Summaries of the Times report say Cantor arranged or helped arrange that offering; the document shows it as one agent of 6.

The stake through Tether is indirect and small. Tether reported 37,729,510 Bitdeer Class A shares in June, 19.7% of the class on the year-end count and 16.3% on September’s if unchanged, worth about $211M at the last close. Reports in October 2025, citing Bloomberg, put Cantor’s interest in Tether at about 5%. Read as a pro-rata claim on Tether’s Bitdeer shares, which it may not be, that would be about $11M.

Bitdeer is spending far more than it earns. It spent $478M on capital expenditure in the third quarter against $10.8M of gross profit, and ended it with $213.7M of cash and restricted cash and $1.95B of borrowings. Revenue rose 89% from a year before and the net loss was $125.5M.

About $8.4M of the $1B programme had been sold by September 29; the whole of it is 65% of Bitdeer’s market value

$ millions. Outlined: the maximum under the August 10, 2026 prospectus supplement, on which Cantor is one of 12 sales agents. Pink: net proceeds under that supplement as of September 29. Faint grey: at-the-market proceeds in the third quarter (net) and in the first half of 2026; the first-half sales came under earlier supplements, and the third-quarter figure includes the amount in pink. Strong grey: market value at the November 13 close, the last before the report, on the shares outstanding at September 30. The filings we read do not show sales after September 30.

0$400M$800M$1,200M$1,600MProgramme maximumAugust 10, 2026 supplement; 12 sales agentsMaximum aggregate offering under the August 10, 2026 prospectus supplement: $1,000M$1.0BSold under that supplementnet proceeds as of September 29Net proceeds under the August 10 supplement as of September 29, 2026: about $8.4M≈$8.4MAt-the-market sales, Q3 2026net proceedsAt-the-market net proceeds, quarter to September 30, 2026: $58M$58.0MAt-the-market sales, first half of 2026proceeds, under earlier supplementsAt-the-market proceeds, first half of 2026: $491.9M$491.9MFor scaleBitdeer’s market valueNov 13 close of $5.60 × shares at Sept 30$5.60 × 276,194,816 shares = about $1,547M≈$1.55B
0$800M$1,600MMaximumAug 10 supplementMaximum aggregate offering under the August 10, 2026 prospectus supplement: $1,000M$1.0BSold under itnet, by Sept 29Net proceeds under the August 10 supplement as of September 29, 2026: about $8.4M≈$8.4MQ3 2026 salesnet proceedsAt-the-market net proceeds, quarter to September 30, 2026: $58M$58.0MH1 2026 salesproceedsAt-the-market proceeds, first half of 2026: $491.9M$491.9MFor scaleMarket valueNov 13, $5.60$5.60 × 276,194,816 shares = about $1,547M≈$1.55B

What is not known

No text of either version has been published. The seven countries, the threshold and the split between notification and licence come from people describing drafts. The value of the Nvidia servers at A201 is given only as hundreds of millions of dollars; Bitdeer says it procured more than 100 racks ahead of energisation and gives no price or delivery date, so whether the site would count as already stocked is not known. Whether the worldwide version would stop A201 from serving a Chinese customer, or only require a licence, is not stated in the summaries.

Norway is on the list too. Bitdeer’s Tydal site there carries a 16-year lease to a tenant, Volta Tydal, with a total contract value Bitdeer puts at about $4.7B for 121 MW, subject to the tenant’s right to terminate without fee at year 10. The third-quarter release calls the end customer a leading AI lab and does not name it. Nothing in the summaries connects that site to the rule; a rule aimed at Chinese customers would bear on it only if the customer were Chinese, and Bitdeer has not said who it is.

What this changes on inthesingularity.ai

  • Nvidia after Jensen. Lead: the remote-access rule is a second channel, beside chip licences, through which policy reaches Nvidia’s sales in Southeast Asia. The version that issues, seven countries with notification or worldwide with licences, is the variable.
  • W.126. Lead: Malaysia’s planned reporting law would cover the same sites. Bitdeer alone lists 225.8 MW there with 2.5 MW online, so most of what either rule would touch is not yet built.
  • Lead for a tracker: Bitdeer’s monthly updates give GPUs deployed (4,328 in September), AI cloud recurring revenue and site dates. Its documents give A201 energisation in the first quarter of 2027, readiness in January, go-live in April, and the second quarter in the capacity table.

Sources and method

ItemFigureSource
The reportThe New York Times article, which we could not openThe New York Times, Nov 15
The reportNarrower version: Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, Brazil, South Africa, Norway; future shipments only; notification in place of an automatic licence when Chinese customers train AI models there. A201 is set to open next year with hundreds of millions of dollars of Nvidia servers and is expected to serve Tencent. Cantor was a designated sales agent on an offering of up to $1B this year, was involved in one of up to $250M in 2024, and holds a Bitdeer stake through Tether. No evidence was found that this influenced LutnickAI Weekly, Nov 15
The reportLutnick has been pushing a weaker version; other officials want the rule to apply worldwide; the rule is proposed and under consideration; Commerce said he acts in the best interests of the United States and does not discuss department matters with his sonsThe Yeshiva World, Nov 15
The reportCommerce’s version would apply only above a higher computing-power threshold; Tencent’s use of the site is attributed to one person and described as likely; the department said Lutnick has complied with all ethics agreements; Cantor declined to comment and Bitdeer did not reply; the deals are a tiny part of Cantor’s business and other banks have similar ties; Lutnick transferred his remaining Cantor stake to family as of October 2025ShiftDelete, Nov 15
The reportHigher threshold; Tencent as the customer described as unconfirmedSuperpower Daily, Nov 15
ContextBessent asked Nvidia’s board to answer within 10 days on China sales and said four departments had backed blacklisting Megaspeed for months while Commerce blocked itBloomberg, Nov 15, as summarised by AI Weekly
ContextTrump authorised a crackdown on chip diversion for the third time this year; Bessent pressed Lutnick over his department’s resistance to implementing the export controls; Lutnick appeared to agree but said he needed to check with TrumpAxios, Nov 11, as relayed by Reuters on GV Wire
BitdeerQuarter to September 30, 2026: revenue $320.7M ($169.7M a year before); AI Cloud $20.4M ($1.8M); gross profit $10.8M; net loss $125.5M; adjusted EBITDA $69.6M; capital expenditure $478.0M; cash, equivalents and restricted cash $213.7M; borrowings $1.95B; at-the-market net proceeds $58.0M; AI Cloud backlog about $2.9B; Tydal’s end customer described as a leading AI lab; 231,794,894 Class A and 44,399,922 Class V shares; the capacity table as of October 31, total 3,121.0 MW; A201 “more than $1.7 billion of expected revenue over 5 years”Bitdeer Q3 2026 release, Nov 10 (6-K)
BitdeerSeptember 2026 update: 4,328 GPUs deployed; AI Cloud annual recurring revenue about $86M; backlog about $2.9B, from $0.9B in August; A201 terms repeated, with readiness in January 2027 and go-live in AprilBitdeer operations update, Oct 19 (6-K)
BitdeerA201: about 21.7 MW; off-take commitments for more than 70% of capacity; more than $1.7B of expected revenue over five years; more than 100 Nvidia GB300 NVL72 racks bought ahead of energisation; customers not disclosedBitdeer AI release, Sept 29, as summarised by Let’s Data Science
BitdeerTydal, Norway: lease to Volta Tydal AS with a total contract value of about $4.7B over an initial 16-year term for 121 MW of IT load; the tenant may terminate without fee at year 10Bitdeer 6-K, Aug 10
Share programmeAt-the-market offering of Class A shares, maximum $1,000,000,000; 12 sales agents, Cantor Fitzgerald & Co. among them; commission up to 3.0% of gross sales; last price $10.88 on August 7Bitdeer prospectus supplement, Aug 10
Share programmeAbout $8.4M of net proceeds under the August 10 supplement as of September 29; at-the-market proceeds of $491.9M in the first half of 2026Bitdeer recent developments, Sept 29 (6-K)
Share programmeSales agreement of March 18, 2024, with 6 agents: B. Riley, Cantor Fitzgerald & Co., Needham, StockBlock, Roth and RosenblattBitdeer sales agreement, Mar 18, 2024
SharesClose of $5.60 on November 13, down 8.65% on the dayMarketScreener
SharesTether: 37,729,510 Class A shares, 19.7% of the Class A shares outstanding at December 31, 2025Schedule 13D/A, Amendment No. 13, event date Jun 12
SharesCantor’s interest in Tether, put at about 5% in reports citing this articleBloomberg, Oct 16, 2025

What we read. We could not open the Times article or Bloomberg’s. What the Times reported is taken from summaries by AI Weekly, The Yeshiva World, ShiftDelete and Superpower Daily, and one more that adds nothing we use; where they differ we say so. They word the Times’s finding on influence in three slightly different ways, so we paraphrase it. Bitdeer’s third-quarter release, its September update, its recent-developments exhibit, the August 10 prospectus supplement and 6-K, the 2024 sales agreement and Tether’s Schedule 13D/A were read directly. The September 29 announcement of A201 was read in a summary; its terms are repeated in the two Bitdeer documents we read. Capacity. The table’s 21 rows sum to 3,121.0 MW, the release’s own total. Online: 563 + 500 + 221 + 100 + 84 + 50 + 2.5 = 1,520.5. By country: United States 1,896.5; Bhutan 600; Norway 247.7; Malaysia 225.8; Canada 101; Ethiopia 50. Malaysia: 67 + 65.1 + 60 + 21.7 + 9.5 + 2.5 = 225.8. Malaysia + Norway = 225.8 + 247.7 = 473.5; ÷ 3,121.0 = 15.17%. Online in the two: 2.5 + 84 = 86.5. Johor: 65.1 + 21.7 = 86.8. The release’s first table is headed as online capacity but includes sites with later dates; we count a site as online only where the table says so. Revenue. $1,700M ÷ 5 = $340M; ÷ $86M = 3.95, which we call about four because one figure is “more than” and the other “about”. $800M ÷ 5 = $160M. $20.4M × 4 = $81.6M. $20.4M ÷ $320.7M = 6.36%. $1.7B ÷ $2.9B = 58.6%. 70% of 21.7 MW = 15.2 MW, the least the commitments cover. $320.7M ÷ $169.7M − 1 = 89.0%; the year-before figures are as presented in the November 2026 release. Shares. 231,794,894 + 44,399,922 = 276,194,816. × $5.60 = $1,547M. $1,000M ÷ $5.60 = 178.6M shares; ÷ 276.2M = 64.7%. $1,000M ÷ $1,547M = 64.7%. 1 − 5.60 ÷ 10.88 = 48.5%. $1,000M × 3.0% = $30M. Tether: 37,729,510 ÷ 231,794,894 = 16.28% of Class A; ÷ 276,194,816 = 13.66% of all shares; × $5.60 = $211.3M; × 5% = $10.6M. Caveats: the Tether holding is as of June and the Cantor figure as of October 2025; the look-through treats Cantor’s interest in Tether as a pro-rata equity claim and is for scale only; we did not open the Bloomberg article behind the 5%. The market value prices the unlisted Class V shares at the Class A price. The $1B maximum includes an amount carried over from the prior supplement, and sales after September are not disclosed, so what remains unsold is not known. The $250M size of the 2024 programme is from the summaries, not the 2024 agreement itself. We read only part of the prospectus supplement. Not used: a senator’s comments, which sources date differently against the report; an earlier account of the seven-country draft that described licences, which we could not open.

Wire reports are written within hours of the news, on a six-hour schedule. Each lists its sources and shows the arithmetic behind its figures. Not investment advice.