W.130SemiAnalysis says over 1.5 GW of restricted Nvidia chips reached China, but gives no count
SemiAnalysis says its model has tracked more than 1.5 GW of restricted Nvidia chips that ended up in China. It gives no chip count, period or dollar value. The “up to 1.5 million” in headlines is Tom’s Hardware’s conversion at 1,000 W a chip; at 700 W the same arithmetic gives about 2.14 million. The $7.5B and 240,000 chips often quoted beside it come from The Information and concern one network. Epoch AI’s median estimate through 2025 was 660,000 H100-equivalents. Nvidia has said diversion is insignificant.
What SemiAnalysis published, and what was added
SemiAnalysis published a power figure and nothing more specific. In a post dated November 12, the research firm says its Accelerator Model, which it says tracks every AI chip’s production and destination, has tracked more than 1.5 GW of Nvidia chips that are restricted and still ended up in China. The figure leaves out chips that, in its words, Nvidia “created to circumvent US rules”, meaning its China-specific parts. The free portion of the post, where the claim appears, gives no number of chips, no split by model, no period and no dollar value, and does not explain the method beyond naming the model.
The chip count is Tom’s Hardware’s arithmetic. Its article of November 13 says SemiAnalysis does not disclose the number of accelerators or how it converts them to power, then divides 1.5 GW by an assumed 1,000 W for each B200-class chip to get 1.5 million, and by 700 W for H200-class chips to get about 2.142 million; the exact quotient is 2,142,857. The headline shown in search results for Tom’s Hardware’s own page says “up to 1.5 million”, and the article’s text uses the same phrase; by its own arithmetic that is the lower figure. The copy syndicated by Yahoo carries a headline without the count. The article writes of “recent years”; SemiAnalysis states no period. If SemiAnalysis’s gigawatts measure facility power, not chip power, the count would be lower than either.
The $7.5B and 240,000 chips are from a different report. Summaries have set them beside the 1.5 GW. They come from The Information, which reported around November 10 that a network of companies in China and Singapore tied to Alice Huang handled at least $7.5B of shipments, about 240,000 chips, by the accounts of outlets that relayed it. Those accounts say the chips were H100, H200 and some A100, and that some were covered by US export controls, which implies not all were. Techzine said Reuters could not verify the report. Tom’s Hardware cites it as one report’s claim. About 240,000 chips is 11% to 16% of Tom’s Hardware’s converted range.
SemiAnalysis also makes a claim about cause, as a belief. It writes that it believes Jensen Huang’s resignation is directly tied to the smuggling of chips, and that the Commerce Department now believes more than 1.5 GW of Nvidia chips are in China. Nvidia’s filing on the resignation gives no reason. We found no Commerce Department statement on the figure, and Tom’s Hardware notes there is no direct evidence of Huang’s involvement in illegal exports.
Converted to chips, 1.5 GW is 1.5 to 2.14 million; Epoch AI’s median was 660K H100-equivalents
Estimates of restricted Nvidia chips that reached China, in thousands. Pink: Tom’s Hardware’s conversion of SemiAnalysis’s 1.5 GW, 1,500K chips at 1,000 W each with the outline to 2,143K at 700 W each. Strong grey: Epoch AI’s median estimate of chips smuggled through the end of 2025, with the outline to the top of its 90% interval. Faint grey: other counts. The rows are not like for like: Epoch counts H100-equivalents, the others count chips; CNAS covers 2024 only; The Information covers one network; SemiAnalysis states no period.
How it compares
Earlier estimates were lower, and wide. Epoch AI estimated in April that a median of 660,000 H100-equivalents had been smuggled into China through the end of 2025, with a 90% interval of 290,000 to 1.6 million, and counted almost 300,000 in documented allegations. CNAS modelled 2024 alone at about 10,000 to several hundred thousand chips, with a median near 140,000. Bloomberg reported on October 1 that US officials put the total at at least the equivalent of 115,000 restricted chips, by The Substrate’s summary. An H100-equivalent is a unit of computing power, so a B200-class chip counts as more than one; a count of chips and a count of H100-equivalents cannot be compared directly.
Nvidia’s position is that diversion is insignificant. It said in October that governments and media had found “insignificant diversion of controlled US products”, MIT Technology Review reported. In the Bloomberg piece it said prosecutors allege that under half of one percent of its products were diverted. We found no Nvidia response to the 1.5 GW figure itself.
The prosecuted cases are far smaller. In the Supermicro case the US indictment alleges at least $510M of servers were diverted to China in about three weeks, out of about $2.5B bought through a Southeast Asian company, by Unite.AI’s account. Taiwanese prosecutors say 74 of 130 B300 servers reached China, and that one executive received more than $21.2M of proceeds. Bloomberg reported on November 15 that Nvidia raised the indictment of its manager in that case with Taiwanese political officials, who said they had no role, according to TNW’s summary.
The largest dollar figures cover chips arranged, shipped or planned; the prosecuted cases are smaller
Dollar figures from reports and court cases about restricted Nvidia chips and China, $ billions, each with its source’s hedge in the hover text, beside Nvidia’s own reported revenue from customers headquartered in China, including Hong Kong (strong grey). Pink: The Information’s figure for one network. Faint grey: other reports and cases. The periods and what is counted differ: the WSJ’s Megaspeed figure covers chips arranged for Chinese firms, including overseas leasing that it says is legal on its face; Reuters counts project plans; the Supermicro figure is servers bought, of which at least $0.51B were allegedly diverted; the Keelung figure is one executive’s alleged proceeds.
The dollar figures
| What | Figure | Source | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Megaspeed, chips for Chinese firms | nearly $12B | WSJ | March 2024 to June 2025; overseas renting is legal on its face, the WSJ says |
| Alice Huang network, shipments | at least $7.5B | The Information | about 240,000 chips; accounts differ on whether all were restricted |
| Chinese projects specifying restricted chips | more than $3.2B | Reuters | 23B yuan of plans and tenders, not installed chips |
| Supermicro case, servers | about $2.5B | US indictment, per Unite.AI | bought through a Southeast Asian company; at least $0.51B allegedly diverted to China in about three weeks |
| Chips smuggled April to July 2025 | over $1B | FT | three months |
| Keelung case, 74 servers | more than $21.2M | Taiwan prosecutors | proceeds to one executive from 74 servers, per prosecutors |
What Nvidia reports
Nvidia booked $19.7B of revenue from China in fiscal 2026, 9.1% of the total. That is revenue from customers headquartered in China, including Hong Kong, in the year to January 25, 2026, down from $25.0B the year before. In the quarter to July 26 it was $7.88B, 8.2% of revenue, and the 10-Q says Hopper shipments to China were less than 1% of data center revenue. Its August outlook assumed no data center compute revenue from China.
The reported figures would not show diverted chips. Chips sold to a buyer headquartered elsewhere and later moved to China are booked under the buyer’s country. The Information’s $7.5B, for which the accounts we read give no period, is 38% of one year’s reported China revenue; the two are not like for like.
For scale, China’s own output and capacity. Epoch AI’s median estimate for Huawei’s Ascend output in 2026 is 1.5 million units, about 880,000 H100-equivalents. SemiAnalysis, in October, put China’s delivered datacenter capacity at over 24 GW as of the end of 2026, by AI Weekly’s summary. 1.5 GW is 6.3% of that, if both measure the same thing, which the sources do not establish.
Nvidia’s reported China revenue fell to $19.7B in fiscal 2026 from $25.0B
Nvidia’s revenue from customers headquartered in China, including Hong Kong, $ billions, for fiscal years 2024 to 2026 (years ending in late January) and, outlined, the first six months of fiscal 2027, from its 10-K and 10-Q. Revenue is assigned by the customer’s headquarters, not by where chips end up.
What this changes on inthesingularity.ai
- How long can Nvidia run without Jensen Huang? Lead: if the pack cites a count of diverted chips, use SemiAnalysis’s own unit, more than 1.5 GW, and label any chip count as a conversion with its watts-per-chip assumption.
- W.106 counted project plans at above 23B yuan and W.126 covered Megaspeed. Lead: keep the three measures apart: plans (Reuters), chips arranged or leased (WSJ, The Information) and chips tracked into China (SemiAnalysis).
- Lead for the compute balance pack: Epoch AI’s 660,000 H100-equivalents and SemiAnalysis’s 1.5 GW are the two published anchors for unreported Chinese compute; neither has a disclosed method that would let one be converted to the other.
- Lead: Nvidia’s 10-Q for the October quarter, due after the November 17 report, is the next filing that could describe investigations or change the China disclosure.
Sources and method
| Item | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| SemiAnalysis | Its Accelerator Model has tracked more than 1.5 GW of restricted Nvidia chips that ended up in China, not counting chips it says Nvidia created to circumvent US rules; no chip count, model mix, period or dollar value; says it believes the resignation is tied to smuggling; says the Commerce Department now believes the same figure | SemiAnalysis, Nov 12 (free portion) |
| Conversion | 1.5 GW ÷ 1,000 W = 1.5 million B200-class chips; ÷ 700 W = about 2.142 million H200-class; SemiAnalysis does not disclose the count or how it converts to power; no direct evidence of Huang’s involvement in illegal exports | Tom’s Hardware, Nov 13, read in Yahoo’s syndicated copy |
| Conversion | Neither prosecution alone approaches 1.5 GW | AI Weekly, Nov 14 |
| One network | At least $7.5B of shipments, about 240,000 chips (H100, H200 and some A100) through companies in China and Singapore; some were covered by US export controls | The Information, about Nov 10, as relayed by TipRanks and Techzine |
| One network | Techzine’s account, which says Reuters could not verify the report | Techzine, Nov 10 |
| Estimates | Median 660,000 H100-equivalents smuggled cumulatively through end-2025; 90% interval 290,000 to 1,600,000; documented allegations almost 300,000 | Epoch AI, Apr 29 |
| Estimates | Smuggling in 2024 could have ranged from about 10,000 to several hundred thousand chips; median about 140,000 | CNAS, Jun 11, 2025 |
| Estimates | US officials: at least the equivalent of 115,000 restricted chips. Nvidia’s reply: prosecutors allege under half of one percent of products diverted | Bloomberg, Oct 1, as summarised by The Substrate |
| Dollar figures | Megaspeed coordinated nearly $12B of advanced chips for Chinese firms, March 2024 to June 2025; renting overseas computing to Chinese customers is legal on its face | WSJ, as summarised by AI Weekly, Nov 15 |
| Dollar figures | More than 23B yuan ($3.2B) of Chinese data-centre projects specifying H100, H200 or H800 chips, from over 150 notices, plans and contracts | Reuters, Nov 13, as summarised by AI Weekly |
| Dollar figures | Supermicro case: about $2.5B of servers bought by a Southeast Asian pass-through company, at least $510M of them diverted to China in about three weeks in spring 2025, per the indictment | Unite.AI |
| Dollar figures | Charges in the Supermicro case were brought in March 2026; Supermicro was not charged | Fortune, Nov 10 |
| Dollar figures | Over $1B of Nvidia chips smuggled April to July 2025 | FT, July 2025, per Epoch AI’s summary |
| Dollar figures | Keelung prosecutors indicted nine on August 24, 2026: 130 B300 servers approved for sale, 74 reached China, 56 seized; one executive allegedly received more than US$21.2M of proceeds | Unite.AI |
| Dollar figures | Nvidia raised its manager’s indictment with Taiwanese political officials, who said they had no role; Nvidia said it found no sign its employee knew of the diversion | Bloomberg, Nov 15, as summarised by TNW |
| Nvidia | Revenue from customers headquartered in China, including Hong Kong: FY2024 $12,330M; FY2025 $25,048M; FY2026 $19,677M; fiscal 2026 total revenue $215,938M | Nvidia 10-K, year to Jan 25, 2026 |
| Nvidia | Quarter to July 26, 2026: China $7,880M ($3,985M a year before); first half $12,430M; total revenue $96,221M; Hopper shipments to China less than 1% of data center revenue | Nvidia 10-Q |
| Nvidia | Outlook assumes no data center compute revenue from China | Nvidia CFO commentary, Aug 26 |
| Nvidia | Statement of October 2026 that governments and media have found insignificant diversion | MIT Technology Review, Nov 12 |
| Nvidia | The board accepted Huang’s resignation, effective immediately; no reason given | Nvidia 8-K, Nov 12 |
| Context | Huawei Ascend output: about 800,000 units in 2025; median estimate 1.5 million units in 2026, about 880,000 H100-equivalents | Epoch AI, Sep 2026 |
| Context | China has over 24 GW of delivered datacenter capacity | SemiAnalysis, Oct 2026, as summarised by AI Weekly |
| Context | Four chip bills are being pushed for the defense authorization bill; the House speaker said a consensus is developing in Congress | Reuters, Nov 13, via Yahoo |
What we read. The free portion of SemiAnalysis’s post, which contains the 1.5 GW claim; the final section is behind a paywall. Tom’s Hardware’s article in Yahoo’s syndicated copy, published November 13 at 11:41 UTC, which carries a different headline, without the chip count, from the one shown in search results for Tom’s Hardware’s own page, which we could not open. The Information, the WSJ, Bloomberg, Reuters and the FT were not opened; what they reported is taken from the outlets named in the table. Nvidia’s filings, Epoch AI and CNAS were read directly. Conversion. 1.5 GW = 1,500,000,000 W. ÷ 1,000 W = 1,500,000 chips; ÷ 700 W = 2,142,857 chips. Both divisors are Tom’s Hardware’s assumptions for chip power; SemiAnalysis states none. Shares. 240,000 ÷ 1,500,000 = 16.0%; ÷ 2,142,857 = 11.2%. 660,000 ÷ 1,500,000 = 44%, mixing H100-equivalents with chips. $19,677M ÷ $215,938M = 9.11%; $7,880M ÷ $96,221M = 8.19%. $7.5B ÷ $19.677B = 38.1%. 1.5 ÷ 24 = 6.25%. Caveats: SemiAnalysis’s figure cannot be checked; it discloses no method, period or count. Its verbs are “ended up in China” and “tracked”; it uses “smuggling” for its claim about the resignation. The secondary accounts of The Information differ on whether all 240,000 chips were restricted when sold. CNAS’s own range is 10,000 to several hundred thousand; Epoch AI restates it as 20,000 to 800,000. Megaspeed denies smuggling. SemiAnalysis’s post gives a different dollar figure for the Keelung case from the prosecutors’ proceeds figure used here. Not used: a price per chip from $7.5B ÷ 240,000, because no account we read says the two figures cover the same shipments; an Epoch estimate from customs data and a think-tank projection for 2026 that we could read only at second hand; a short seller’s claim about illegal sales as a share of revenue.
Wire reports are written within hours of the news, on a six-hour schedule. Each lists its sources and shows the arithmetic behind its figures. Not investment advice.