W.119Broadcom fell 4.8% after Redburn cut its target to $398 over AI financing risk
Rothschild & Co Redburn cut Broadcom to Neutral from Buy on November 13 and lowered its price target from $595 to $398, a third. The shares closed at $347.01, down 4.76%, about $83B of market value; the Philadelphia semiconductor index fell 3.4% the same day. Broadcom’s filings put its maximum backstops on two financings of AI racks at about $43B and about $29B, undiscounted: together about $72B, 3.0 times its cash on August 2.
What Redburn said
Rothschild & Co Redburn moved Broadcom to Neutral from Buy on November 13 and cut its target from $595 to $398. That is a cut of 33.1%. Investing.com names the analyst as Mike Harrison. TIKR puts the lowest target on the stock before the cut at $400; MarketScreener shows a mean of $529.24 across 51 analysts.
The argument, as Investing.com reports it, is about Broadcom’s customers, not its chips. The note says Anthropic and OpenAI must stay ahead of open models and become self-financing “in short order”, and that this is unlikely to happen quickly. It says up to 15 GW for the two labs sits behind Broadcom’s guidance for AI revenue in fiscal 2028, that both labs rely on credit markets, and that about 11 times fiscal 2028 earnings counts for little while the quality of those earnings is in question. It also cites Google’s efforts to diversify away from Broadcom as an analogue for what the labs might do. Redburn changed its valuation method from discounted cash flow to sum of the parts.
We did not read the note. Everything above is from press reports of it. The 456X brief of November 14 attributes to Redburn an estimate of up to about $43B of residual value exposure on a $63B lease tied to Anthropic. Those two numbers match Broadcom’s own filing and the arrangers’ announcement of October 26; Investing.com’s account of the note has neither.
Redburn’s new target is 15% above where the shares closed
Broadcom share price levels, in dollars per share. Pink: Redburn’s new target. Black: the close on November 13, the day of the downgrade. Strong grey: closes on November 12 and November 6. Grey: the low during November 13. Faint grey: Redburn’s previous target, the mean target of 51 analysts as MarketScreener shows it, and the 52-week high and low. Targets are analysts’ estimates of a future price; the others are traded prices.
The share price
Broadcom closed at $347.01, down $17.35 or 4.76%. Reports that it fell 6% or 7% describe the morning: the low was $337.67, 7.3% below the previous close. On 4.77B shares, the count on the cover of its last quarterly filing, the day’s fall is about $82.8B of market value and leaves about $1.66T.
The fall gave back most of the previous day’s gain. The shares rose 5.5% on November 12, from $345.22 to $364.36, the day Nvidia announced that Jensen Huang had left. From the November 6 close of $293.69 to the November 12 close they rose 24%; International Business Times reports that Redburn called the recent move into the stock a trade on sentiment. After the downgrade the shares are still 18% above the November 6 close and 30% below the 52-week high of $495.00.
Chip stocks fell that day with or without a downgrade. CappNotes’ closing summary has the Philadelphia semiconductor index down 3.4%, AMD down 8.75% and Nvidia down 2.01%. Broadcom fell 1.4 points more than the index. Applied to the whole company, that difference is about $24B of the $83B.
Broadcom fell 1.4 points more than the chip index on the day
Change from the November 12 close to the November 13 close, in percent. Pink: Broadcom, from its two closing prices. Faint grey: AMD, Nvidia, the Philadelphia semiconductor index, the Nasdaq Composite and the S&P 500, as listed in CappNotes’ closing summary for November 13. Broadcom is a member of all three indexes, so the index moves include its own.
What Broadcom has guaranteed
Broadcom’s filing of October 27 puts its maximum liability on the newer financing at approximately $43B. Financial partners take on a portion of certain agreements to buy AI racks built on Broadcom-designed accelerators, and the related leases with a customer. If the customer defaults, Broadcom covers any difference between 72.5% of the outstanding amounts owed on the lease and the value realized on the racks. The maximum is undiscounted and applies once the racks are deployed; it rises with deliveries and falls as rent is paid. Broadcom calls it a contingent liability with “a low probability of occurring”. The filing names neither the customer nor the lenders. Bank of America, Blackstone, Citi and Morgan Stanley announced a $63B financing for Broadcom accelerators and networking equipment leased to Anthropic on October 26, as W.114 set out.
An earlier financing carries a second backstop of approximately $29B. Broadcom’s filing for the quarter to August 2 describes an initial tranche of $35B launched in June, on which it covers the difference between 85% of outstanding lease amounts and the value of the racks over five-year leases. It had paid nothing under it. The customer may also issue Broadcom up to $42B of convertible notes; none had been issued at August 2.
Added together the two maximums are about $72B. No filing adds them, and they need not peak at the same time, since each falls as rent is paid. For scale: $72B is 3.0 times Broadcom’s cash of $24.0B on August 2, 1.8 times its free cash flow over the four quarters to that date, $39.4B, and 4.3% of its market value at the November 13 close. Broadcom carried $59.4B of debt. The $83B of market value lost on November 13 is larger than both maximums combined.
The leases Anthropic reports are larger than either financing. Anthropic’s amended prospectus counts about $161.2B of rent, excluding interest, under equipment leases with Broadcom and financing entities, as W.084 reported. Broadcom reported $16.7B of AI semiconductor revenue in the quarter to August 2 and guided to $21.7B for the quarter after. It reports that quarter on December 9.
The two maximums together are 3.0 times Broadcom’s cash and less than one day’s fall
$ billions. Pink: Broadcom’s maximum potential liability under each backstop, as its filings state it: undiscounted, upon deployment of the racks. On our reading that is a default after full deployment with nothing recovered from the racks. Dashed: the two added, which is our sum. Strong grey: Broadcom’s cash on August 2, 2026, and its free cash flow (cash from operations less capital expenditures) in the quarter and the four quarters to that date. Grey: its debt. Black: the market value lost on November 13, the fall in the share price times shares outstanding at August 28. A maximum, a balance, a flow and a market value are different kinds of number; the chart is for scale only.
The two backstops and Broadcom’s quarter
| Item | Amount | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| October financing: maximum backstop | about $43B | 72.5% of amounts owed, less rack value; 8-K of October 27 |
| June financing: maximum backstop | about $29B | 85% of amounts owed, less rack value; 10-Q for the quarter to August 2 |
| The two added | $72B | our sum |
| Cash and equivalents | $23.975B | August 2, 2026 |
| Debt | $59.419B | $2.252B short-term plus $57.167B long-term |
| Free cash flow, quarter | $13.665B | $14.197B less $0.532B |
| Free cash flow, four quarters | $39.403B | nine months $31.937B plus $7.466B |
| Market value at the November 13 close | $1656B | $347.01 × 4.774B shares |
| Market value lost, November 13 | $82.8B | $17.35 × 4.774B shares |
What this changes on inthesingularity.ai
- W.114 set Broadcom’s backstops beside Nvidia’s guarantees. Lead: a series of supplier market value against maximum guarantees (Broadcom 4.3%) would show how the market weighs them.
- Can Anthropic’s compute keep up with its demand? Lead: Redburn’s case, as reported, turns on whether Anthropic becomes self-financing before the racks deploy from 2027. The pack’s cash path against the $161.2B of equipment rent is the test.
- W.116: Broadcom is one of the seven firms in the Fed’s count of leases and guarantees. Its two maximums, $72B, are unchanged by the downgrade.
- Lead for a tracker: Broadcom’s December 9 results should restate both maximums and say whether any convertible notes, up to $42B, have been issued.
Sources and method
| Item | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| The downgrade | Rothschild & Co Redburn, analyst Mike Harrison, November 13: Broadcom cut to Neutral, target $398 from $595; the two labs must become self-financing “in short order”, which the note calls unlikely to occur quickly; about 11 times fiscal 2028 earnings on guidance; up to 15 GW for Anthropic and OpenAI behind Broadcom’s fiscal 2028 AI revenue guidance; valuation moved from discounted cash flow to sum of the parts | Investing.com, Nov 13 |
| The downgrade | Downgrade to Neutral from Buy; shares fell after it | MT Newswires via MarketScreener, Nov 13 |
| The downgrade | Independent broker estimates: residual value guarantee exposure of up to about $43B on a $63B lease tied to Anthropic, attributed to Redburn | 456X Morning Brief, Nov 14 |
| Share price | Closes of $364.36 on November 12 and $347.01 on November 13; November 13 range $337.67–$358.47; 52-week range $289.77–$495.00; a fall of as much as 7.3% during the day | JKN, Nov 13; The Motley Fool, Nov 13 |
| Share price | Close of $345.22 on November 11 | Trefis, Nov 12 |
| Share price | Close of $293.69 on November 6; Redburn called the recent move into the shares a trade on sentiment | International Business Times Australia, Nov 13 |
| Targets | Mean target $529.24 across 51 analysts (MarketScreener); the lowest target before the cut was $400 and the consensus about $533 (TIKR) | TIKR, Nov 13 |
| The day | November 13: AMD −8.75%; Philadelphia semiconductor index −3.4%; Nvidia −2.01%; Nasdaq Composite −0.91%; S&P 500 −0.4% | CappNotes closing look, Nov 13 |
| October backstop | Financial partners take on a portion of certain agreements to buy AI racks, and the related leases with a customer; if the customer defaults Broadcom covers any difference between 72.5% of the outstanding amounts owed on the lease and the value realized on the racks; maximum potential liability approximately $43B, undiscounted, once the racks are deployed; described as a contingent liability with a low probability of occurring | Broadcom 8-K, filed Oct 27 |
| June backstop | An initial tranche of $35B led by a financial partner; Broadcom covers the difference between 85% of outstanding lease amounts and rack value over five-year lease terms; maximum approximately $29B, undiscounted; nothing paid; the customer may issue Broadcom up to $42B of convertible notes, none issued at August 2; remaining performance obligations about $179.2B; 4,773,629,865 shares outstanding at August 28; nine-month cash from operations $32.95B and capital expenditures $1.013B | Broadcom 10-Q for the quarter ended Aug 2, 2026 |
| Broadcom’s quarter | Quarter ended August 2, 2026: revenue $29.591B; AI semiconductor revenue $16.7B; cash from operations $14.197B; capital expenditures $532M; free cash flow $13.665B; cash $23.975B; debt $2,252M short-term and $57,167M long-term; fourth-quarter guidance of about $34.8B of revenue and $21.7B of AI semiconductor revenue | Broadcom third-quarter release, Sept 2 |
| Broadcom’s quarter | Free cash flow of $7,466M in the quarter ended November 2, 2025 | Broadcom fourth-quarter fiscal 2025 release |
| Anthropic | Equipment leases with Broadcom and financing entities of about $161.2B of rent, excluding interest | Anthropic’s amended prospectus, as read for W.084 |
| Calendar | Broadcom reports fourth-quarter results on December 9, after the close | ts2.tech, Nov 13 |
Redburn’s note was not read; its contents are from Investing.com and other press reports. Share prices are closing prices from market data pages and press reports, not from an exchange feed. Moves: (347.01 − 364.36) ÷ 364.36 = −4.76%; (364.36 − 345.22) ÷ 345.22 = +5.54%; low (337.67 − 364.36) ÷ 364.36 = −7.33%; November 6 to November 12, +24.06%, and to November 13, +18.16%; against the 52-week high, −29.90%. Target: (398 − 595) ÷ 595 = −33.1%; 398 ÷ 347.01 − 1 = +14.7%. Market value: 17.35 × 4773.6M shares = $82.8B; 347.01 × 4773.6M = $1656.5B. The share count is from August 28 and will have changed a little. Against the index: 4.76 − 3.4 = 1.36 points; × the November 12 market value of $1739.3B = $23.7B. This is a subtraction, not an estimate of what the downgrade caused. Backstops: 43 + 29 = 72; ÷ cash 23.975 = 3.00; ÷ four-quarter free cash flow 39.403 = 1.83; ÷ market value 1656.5 = 4.35%; 43 ÷ cash = 1.79. Free cash flow: quarter 14197 − 532 = 13665; nine months 32950 − 1013 = 31937; plus 7466 = 39403, $M. Debt: 2252 + 57167 = 59419, $M. Not used: the price of the record close in June, which we could not confirm; trading volume, on which sources differ; reports that Broadcom is weighing a backstop for OpenAI, for which we found no filing; and descriptions of the $63B as a guarantee, which is the size of the financing, not of Broadcom’s exposure.
Wire reports are written within hours of the news, on a six-hour schedule. Each lists its sources and shows the arithmetic behind its figures. Not investment advice.