027How big is AI revenue when each dollar is counted once?
Aswath Damodaran puts all revenue from AI products and services at about $250B a year. Sam Altman is reported to have said AI demand has been double-counted. Added up the way companies report it, AI revenue ran at $456B a year in the third quarter, and $161B of that was one AI company paying another. Counted once it was $295B. We estimate about $369B by the end of 2026 and $716B by the end of 2027, in a range of $507B to $929B. More than half of the 2027 figure is OpenAI and Anthropic.
Two numbers that don’t match the filings
On November 9 Aswath Damodaran, who teaches valuation at NYU, wrote that revenue from AI products and services is “about $250 billion” a year, even on the run-rates the labs leak. He used the same figure in August, when it included more than $65B for Anthropic and about $40B for OpenAI. Two days after his post, Korea’s Financial News reported that Sam Altman had told Samsung executives “there has been double-counting of demand” (W.091).
Company filings point the other way. Microsoft, Amazon and Alphabet reported cloud growth of 39% to 103%, most of it AI by the measure below. Oracle, CoreWeave and SpaceX rent out compute by the gigawatt. Meta says AI is already adding to its ad revenue. Add every line and the total is far above $250B. The lines overlap, though. A customer pays Anthropic; Anthropic pays Amazon and SpaceX for compute; all three book revenue.
This pack counts each dollar once, where it comes in from a customer that is not itself selling AI. That leaves four layers: what customers pay the labs, what they pay the big clouds for AI directly, what they pay other software companies for AI products, and the extra ad revenue Meta and Google earn because AI ranks their ads. Chips, servers, power and buildings are left out altogether. They are the capex, which this revenue has to pay for.
Added up, $456B a year. Counted once, $295B
Third quarter of 2026 at a yearly rate, $B. Solid: revenue from customers outside the AI supply chain, which we keep. Dashed: revenue paid by another company in the tally, which we take out. Labs: OpenAI’s and Anthropic’s third-quarter revenue times four. Clouds: AI revenue at Azure, AWS and Google Cloud, each against its no-AI trend. Other compute: Oracle’s cloud infrastructure, CoreWeave and what SpaceX sells Anthropic, latest quarter times four. Software: Menlo Ventures’ September estimate. Ads: calendar 2026.
Data
| $B a year, Q3 2026 | Added up | Taken out | Counted once | What comes out |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenAI and Anthropic | $107.8B | — | $107.8B | Nothing: this is what customers pay for the models |
| AI at Azure, AWS, Google Cloud | $147.8B | $77.7B | $70.0B | What OpenAI and Anthropic pay the three; Google’s TPU systems, which are hardware |
| Oracle, CoreWeave, SpaceX compute | $64.3B | $64.3B | — | All of it: sold to the labs and the hyperscalers |
| AI software outside the labs | $54.1B | $18.9B | $35.2B | 35%, paid on to labs and clouds for models and compute |
| AI in Meta’s and Google’s ads | $82.2B | — | $82.2B | Nothing: advertisers are the customers |
| All five | $456.2B | $161.0B | $295.2B | 35% of the sum |
The labs are counted in full
Anthropic’s amended S-1 puts third-quarter revenue at $16.96B. OpenAI told investors its own was about $10B. Together that is $108B a year. Both have grown since. Anthropic’s run-rate was about $81B on October 31, up $10B in a month, and our revenue tracker had the two at $143B on November 11. It puts them at $167B at the end of December (Anthropic $94B, OpenAI $73B) and $385B at the end of 2027 (Anthropic $185B, OpenAI $199B).
The two are not on the same basis. Anthropic books the full price of Claude sold through Amazon’s, Google’s and Microsoft’s marketplaces, which carried 44% of its revenue in the first nine months, and expenses the clouds’ cut. OpenAI books only its share of some sales through Microsoft. We leave both as reported. Anthropic’s figure is what customers paid, and the clouds’ cut comes out of the cloud layer below.
Two-thirds of the compute revenue comes from inside the industry
Packs 011 and 013 measured AI revenue at Google Cloud, Azure and AWS by setting each against an estimate of what it would have grown without AI (22%, 17% and 14.5% a year) and crediting 90% of the gap to AI. With the third quarter in, that is $13.9B at Google Cloud, $12.8B at Azure and $10.2B at AWS for the quarter, $148B a year.
Microsoft’s 10-Q says how much of Azure’s is one customer. It recorded $10.0B of “revenue from commercial arrangements with OpenAI, inclusive of revenue-sharing payments” in the quarter, about 11% of its revenue. That is 78% of Azure’s AI revenue as we measure it, if all of it sits in Azure, and as much as OpenAI’s own revenue for the quarter.
Anthropic’s filing gives a ceiling for the other two. It spent $9.86B on compute in the quarter and $2.36B on sales, marketing and partnerships, a line that in the first half was mostly fees to channel partners, chiefly the cloud marketplaces. The two come to 72% of its revenue. SpaceX’s 10-Q shows one customer of its AI segment at 34.5% of revenue, about $5.03B, and Bloomberg has reported that Anthropic is SpaceX’s largest customer. That is 67% of the segment’s $7.56B, and it leaves $4.83B of Anthropic’s compute bill for every other supplier. If all of that and all of the sales and marketing line went to Amazon and Google, $7.20B together, it would be 30% of their $24.1B of AI revenue. OpenAI’s $38B contract with AWS, spread evenly over its seven years, adds $1.4B a quarter and takes that to 35%. We take a third. Across the three clouds that makes the two labs about half of AI revenue (49%).
Google Cloud needs one more adjustment. Alphabet began booking sales of TPU systems to other data center operators in the second quarter and called them a meaningful contributor in the third, without giving a figure. That is hardware, the same kind of revenue as Nvidia’s. We take out a further 10% of Google Cloud’s AI revenue for it, which may be low: Alphabet’s inventory rose from $2.4B to $10.0B in the first half of the year.
Oracle, CoreWeave and SpaceX’s compute sales are left out entirely. Oracle’s cloud infrastructure brought in $7.39B in its August quarter, and its backlog includes a contract with OpenAI reported at about $300B. Three customers were 72% of CoreWeave’s second-quarter revenue. Whatever these companies sell to enterprises and governments directly is revenue we do not count, so our total is a little low. Of the $212B a year of cloud AI and rented compute in the tally, $70B survives.
Who paid for the compute in the third quarter
$B in the quarter. Pink: paid by OpenAI or Anthropic. Azure’s is Microsoft’s disclosed revenue from OpenAI; SpaceX’s is the one customer in its 10-Q; the third at AWS and Google Cloud is our estimate from Anthropic’s filing. Dashed: Google’s TPU systems, which are hardware, our estimate. Strong grey: everyone else, the part we keep. Faint grey: not split by customer and not kept.
Data
| Q3 2026, $B | Revenue | Growth | No-AI path | AI revenue | AI, × 4 | Q4 revenue | AI at year-end, × 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Azure | $33.16B | 48% | $18.95B | $12.80B | $51.2B | $36.07B | $58.3B |
| AWS | $46.00B | 39% | $34.61B | $10.25B | $41.0B | $49.81B | $48.5B |
| Google Cloud | $30.71B | 103% | $15.27B | $13.89B | $55.6B | $35.00B | $65.9B |
| Three clouds | $109.88B | $36.94B | $147.8B | $120.88B | $172.7B |
AI revenue is 90% of revenue above the no-AI path. Azure’s fourth quarter is the middle of Microsoft’s 49–50% guidance; AWS’s is our estimate of 40% growth and Google Cloud’s our estimate of $35.0B. Kept: $11.2B a year at Azure and $58.8B at AWS and Google Cloud in the third quarter; $11.7B and $69.7B at the end of 2026.
Software sold outside the labs
Menlo Ventures estimates that enterprises were spending $176.8B a year on using AI in September, 5.4 times last year’s $33B. Of that, $122.7B went to Anthropic, OpenAI and Google, which sit in the first two layers here. The other $54.1B went to everyone else: $37.3B for applications (about $10B for coding tools other than Claude Code and Codex, $9.5B for assistants such as Microsoft’s Copilot, $8.8B for other horizontal software and $10.1B for vertical software) and $16.8B for other models, inference platforms and agent infrastructure.
These vendors buy models from the labs and compute from the clouds, so part of their revenue is already counted above. We keep 65%, or $35B. That share is a judgment. A coding tool that resells tokens keeps less of what it charges; a vertical application with its own workflow keeps more.
The ads
Pack 011 put AI’s part of Meta’s ad revenue at $55B in 2026, 22% of it, and of Google’s at $29.5B, using the same kind of trend. Meta’s figure already had its third quarter in it. Google’s did not. Search grew 12%, where we had pencilled in 15%, and added $79M on the second quarter even as Alphabet reported its fastest query growth in five years. With that quarter in, Google’s figure is $27B, 8% of its ad revenue.
Nobody buys this revenue as AI. Advertisers pay for clicks, and the estimate turns on what Meta and Google would have grown without the new ranking models. We include it because it is the return on the largest AI capex outside the clouds, and we show the total without it throughout: $213B in the third quarter and $287B at the end of 2026.
About $369B by the end of 2026 and $716B by the end of 2027
AI revenue counted once, $B a year. The third quarter is reported figures times four; the end of 2026 is our estimate seven weeks out; the end of 2027 is shown for three cases. The ads layer is a calendar-year figure (2026 for the first two bars, 2027 for the rest), because ad revenue is seasonal.
| $B a year | Q3 2026 | End of 2026 | End of 2027, low | Base | High |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenAI and Anthropic | $108B | $167B | $283B | $385B | $489B |
| AI at the three clouds, outside the labs | $70B | $81B | $89B | $153B | $209B |
| AI software outside the labs | $35B | $39B | $42B | $66B | $98B |
| Sold as AI | $213B | $287B | $414B | $603B | $796B |
| AI in Meta’s and Google’s ads | $82B | $82B | $94B | $113B | $133B |
| Counted once | $295B | $369B | $507B | $716B | $929B |
What 2027 rests on
The end-2027 figure is 1.9 times the end-2026 one. Of the $347B added, 63% comes from the two labs.
Labs. The tracker carries each lab’s recent monthly growth forward and halves it every 18 months. On that path Anthropic books about $138B of revenue in 2027. Goldman Sachs, the lead bank on its IPO, is telling investors $136B, the FT reported. OpenAI’s path, about $130B, is less well supported. Its own projection in February was $62B, a level its December target for run-rate would already pass. FutureSearch, an outside forecaster, put its run-rate at $92B in June 2027 when it last updated on October 16, with a 10th-to-90th-percentile range of $63.5B to $132.5B. The tracker has $127B by then, near the top of that range. The low case halves both labs’ growth every six months, which leaves them at $283B together at the end of 2027. The high case does not fade it at all, $489B. The tracker’s own ranges are wider, $262B to $668B if both labs land at the same end.
For Anthropic, compute does not stop the base case. On pack 017’s lowest supply path, 8 GW by the end of 2027 with research keeping its share of the compute, it can serve about $185B a year, the tracker’s central figure. On that pack’s base path, 10 GW, it can serve $231B. We have no equivalent check for OpenAI.
Clouds. Amazon projects AWS growth of over 40% in both 2027 and 2028. Microsoft guided Azure to 49–50% for the December quarter. Alphabet expects just over 55% of Google Cloud’s $561B backlog to become revenue within 24 months. The base case has the three growing 40%, 40% and 50% in the fourth quarter of 2027, with the labs’ shares unchanged. The low case has them growing 32%, 30% and 35%, with more of it paid by the labs.
Software and ads. Software outside the labs grows 1.7 times in the base case; Menlo has its segments growing 2.3 to 4.3 times in the year to September. Meta’s and Google’s ad revenue grow 18% and 11%, pack 011’s assumptions.
Against Damodaran’s $250B
On November 11 the things sold as AI, counted once, were running at about $256B a year: $143B at the labs, with the cloud and software layers halfway between their third-quarter and year-end levels. Damodaran’s figure is about right for today.
It is a rate, and it is moving. The same $250B in August included about $105B for the two labs. They are at $143B now, and Anthropic alone added $10B in October. On our estimate the comparable figure is $287B at the end of December and $603B a year later.
His test for the industry is about $5T of revenue within a decade, 20 times $250B. From $603B it is 8 times.
Against the capex
Amazon, Alphabet, Meta and Microsoft have guided to about $730B of capex between them in 2026, and the Street case in pack 021 has $1.01T in 2027. Revenue counted once is 0.51× the first at the end of 2026 and 0.71× the second at the end of 2027 (0.50× to 0.92× across our cases).
That compares a yearly rate at one date with a year of spending, and a dollar of capex earns for several years, so a ratio under one is not a shortfall by itself. Packs 011 and 013 work through what the ad and cloud revenue returns on the capex behind it. The ratio does say which way things are going: the revenue is growing faster than the spending, from well under it.
What would move it
- Compute that arrives late. Microsoft lowered its calendar-2026 capex to about $170B because third-party capacity was delayed, and pack 020 has Texas switching on 2.38 GW less by the end of 2027 under its incoming governor than on the path the outgoing one had set. Late capacity lowers the cloud layer first and the labs after it.
- Prices. Anthropic said price reductions and discounts took about $600M off its third-quarter revenue (W.001), and it listed Fable 5.2 at 20% below Fable 5.1 (pack 025).
- Budgets. In Menlo’s survey the average enterprise spent 4.7 times last year’s AI budget against a planned 1.9. A year spent catching budgets up would slow every layer.
- The accounting basis. If Anthropic booked marketplace sales net, as OpenAI does, the labs layer would fall by the clouds’ cut and the cloud layer would rise by the same amount. The total would not change.
- The trends. The cloud and ad layers depend on what each business would have grown without AI. At the low and high ends of the ranges packs 011 and 013 used, the end-2026 total is $396B or $341B.
What is not counted
China’s clouds and labs: Alibaba alone said its AI-related products were selling at an annualized RMB35.8B in the March quarter. Consumer AI outside the two labs, such as Gemini subscriptions and Grok. AI in other ad businesses: AppLovin’s revenue grew 55% in the third quarter, to $2.19B. Compute that Oracle and the neoclouds rent directly to enterprises and governments. Consulting, and robotaxis. Each would raise the total.
What to watch
Anthropic’s first report as a public company. It expects to list next week. Whether it keeps publishing run-rate, and what share of revenue goes through the clouds’ marketplaces.
OpenAI’s December run-rate against its target of at least $70B, which the tracker’s year-end figure follows.
Microsoft’s next 10-Q, in late January: the line for revenue from OpenAI, $10.0B this quarter.
Whether Alphabet puts a number on TPU system sales, which would settle how much of Google Cloud’s growth is hardware.
AWS’s fourth quarter against Amazon’s projection of more than 40% growth in 2027.
What this is anchored on
Company figures are as reported or as the filings’ readers reported them. The no-AI trends are those of packs 011 and 013. The labs’ shares of cloud revenue, the share software vendors keep and every 2027 growth rate are ours.
| Item | Data point | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Damodaran | Revenue from AI products and services “about $250 billion”, on the run-rates leaked by the leading companies | Musings on Markets, Nov 9 |
| Damodaran | August: no more than $250B, including more than $65B at Anthropic and about $40B at OpenAI; about $5T of revenue needed within a decade, about 20 times that | MIT Sloan Management Review India |
| Altman | Remarks to Samsung executives on Oct 31, as Financial News reported them on Nov 11 | inthesingularity.ai W.091 |
| Labs | Run-rates on Nov 11: Anthropic $83.5B, OpenAI $59.6B; December 2026: $94.1B and $72.5B; December 2027: $185.2B ($123B–369B) and $199.3B ($140B–299B); the paths with growth halving every 6 months or not at all | inthesingularity.ai revenue tracker, run of Nov 11 |
| Anthropic | Third quarter: revenue $16,956M; compute and infrastructure $9,863M; sales, marketing and partnerships $2,361M; price reductions and discounts took about $600M off revenue | inthesingularity.ai W.001, from the S-1/A of Nov 2 |
| Anthropic | Cloud marketplaces carried 48% of revenue in the first half and 44% in the first nine months | Filing Insights, on the S-1/A |
| Anthropic | Marketplace sales are booked gross, as principal; the clouds remit net of their fees | Anthropic S-1, Oct 26 |
| Anthropic | First half: sales, marketing and partnerships $3.168B, including a $2.7B increase in fees paid to channel partners | PPC Land, on the S-1 |
| Anthropic | Run-rate about $81B on Oct 31, up $10B from Sep 30 | Reuters, via MarketScreener, on the S-1/A of Nov 10 |
| Anthropic | Goldman Sachs, lead bank on the IPO: revenue of about $52B in 2026 and $136B in 2027 (FT) | investingLive, Nov 11 |
| Anthropic | Commitments by supplier; the Google, Amazon and Microsoft minimums | inthesingularity.ai W.084 and W.091 |
| OpenAI | Third-quarter revenue about $10B, up about 50% on the second; run-rate about $50B at the end of September. Anthropic expects to list next week | inthesingularity.ai W.079, from the WSJ and Bloomberg |
| OpenAI | Books only its share of some sales through Microsoft; Anthropic books marketplace sales in full | The SaaS CFO |
| OpenAI | February projections: revenue of $30B in 2026 and $62B in 2027 | MLQ, on The Information |
| OpenAI | Forecast of its run-rate in June 2027: median $92B, 10th percentile $63.5B, 90th $132.5B, from about $50B at the end of September; last updated Oct 16 | FutureSearch |
| Microsoft | “revenue from commercial arrangements with OpenAI, inclusive of revenue-sharing payments, of $10.0 billion” in the quarter to Sep 30; receivables from OpenAI $7.2B | Microsoft 10-Q, Oct 28 |
| Microsoft | That is about 11% of revenue; $24.1B on the same measure in the twelve months to June | The Next Web, on the 10-Q |
| Microsoft | Azure revenue $33.17B, up 48%, the first figure in dollars; December quarter guided to 49–50% in constant currency | SiliconANGLE, Oct 28 |
| Microsoft | Calendar-2026 capex about $170B, lower because third-party capacity was delayed | Walnut, on the Oct 28 call |
| Amazon | AWS sales $46.0B, up 39.3%; a $184B run-rate; growth projected at over 40% in both 2027 and 2028 | TelecomTV, on Amazon’s release |
| Alphabet | Google Cloud $30.71B from $15.16B; Search & other $63.35B; YouTube ads $11.21B; Network $7.46B; Google advertising $82.01B from $74.18B | Verdict, on Alphabet’s release |
| Alphabet | Cloud backlog $561B, just over 55% of it expected as revenue within 24 months; TPU system sales a meaningful contributor | MarketBeat, Q3 call highlights |
| Alphabet | TPU system sales first booked in the second quarter; no figure given; inventory $10.0B at Jun 30, from $2.4B at the end of 2025 | TIKR, on the 10-Q |
| Alphabet | Search revenue rose $79M on the second quarter while query growth was the fastest in five years | PPC Land, Oct 28 |
| SpaceX | Third-quarter revenue $14.58B, AI segment $7.56B; one customer of that segment was 34.5% of revenue; Bloomberg reported that Anthropic is SpaceX’s largest customer | FourWeekMBA, on the 10-Q; inthesingularity.ai W.043 |
| CoreWeave | Third-quarter revenue $3,661M; backlog about $132.5B | inthesingularity.ai W.076 |
| CoreWeave | Second quarter: three customers were 36%, 26% and 10% of revenue | sec-api.io, on the 10-Q |
| Oracle | Cloud infrastructure revenue $7.39B in the quarter to Aug 31, up 121%; remaining performance obligations $664B | Oracle, first-quarter fiscal 2027 results |
| Oracle | OpenAI’s contract reported at about $300B, not confirmed by Oracle | inthesingularity.ai W.061 |
| Amazon | OpenAI’s AWS agreements: $38B over seven years (November 2025) and $100B over eight (February 2026) | inthesingularity.ai W.061 |
| Software | Enterprise spending on using AI $176.8B (September 2026, annualized; $33B in 2025): applications $77.3B, infrastructure $99.5B; $122.7B at Anthropic, OpenAI and Google, $40.0B of it their own applications; coding $34.0B, of which Claude Code and Codex $24.0B; assistants outside the labs $9.5B; other horizontal $8.8B; vertical $10.1B; the average enterprise spent 4.7 times last year’s AI budget against a planned 1.9 | Menlo Ventures, 2026: The State of Enterprise AI |
| Meta | AI investments “already delivering substantial incremental advertising revenue”; fourth-quarter revenue guided to $73–76B | Meta, third-quarter 2026 results |
| Ads | Method, trends and Meta’s 2026 figure (nine months reported, the fourth quarter at the midpoint of $73–76B guidance) | inthesingularity.ai pack 011 |
| Clouds | Method, trends and the quarterly Azure and AWS series | inthesingularity.ai pack 013 |
| Capex | 2026 guidance: Amazon about $220B, Alphabet $195–205B, Meta $135–145B, Microsoft about $170B. 2027, Street case: Alphabet $300B, Amazon $290B, Microsoft $215B, Meta $205B | inthesingularity.ai pack 021 |
| Compute | Anthropic’s supply paths to 2029 and the revenue each supports; Texas gigawatts switched on later | inthesingularity.ai packs 017 and 020 |
| Not counted | Alibaba: AI-related product revenue at an annualized RMB35.8B in the March quarter, the eleventh of triple-digit growth | National CIO Review |
| Not counted | AppLovin: third-quarter revenue $2,185M, up 55% | AppLovin 8-K, Nov 4 |
Method
What counts. Revenue from a customer that is not itself in the tally. A run-rate is a quarter’s revenue times four, except for the labs at the two year-ends, where it is the tracker’s estimate (Anthropic’s own measure is the last 28 days of consumption times 13 plus monthly subscriptions times 12), and for ads, which are calendar years. Suppliers’ revenue (chips, servers, power, construction) is not AI revenue here.
Labs. Third quarter: Anthropic $16.96B (S-1/A) plus OpenAI about $10B (investor documents, as reported), times four. Year-ends: the revenue tracker’s run of November 11, frozen, so this page does not move when the tracker does. Its December 2026 figure for OpenAI follows OpenAI’s own target. The low and high cases for 2027 are the tracker’s paths with monthly growth halving every 6 months or not fading.
Clouds. AI revenue in a quarter is 90% of revenue above a no-AI path: for AWS and Google Cloud the same quarter of 2023 grown at 14.5% and 22% a year, for Azure the non-AI revenue in Microsoft’s own split for 2024 grown at 17%. These are the methods and rates of packs 013 and 011, applied by quarter. What we keep: at Azure in the third quarter, AI revenue less Microsoft’s $10.0B from OpenAI, and at the year-ends 20% of it (10% and 30% in the low and high cases); at AWS and Google Cloud together, two-thirds (55% and 75%), less 10% of Google Cloud’s for TPU systems sold as hardware (20% and 5%). OpenAI’s $100B AWS agreement of February 2026 has no schedule and is left out of the arithmetic for the labs’ share. Microsoft’s figure includes revenue-sharing payments and the filing does not say which line it sits in. OpenAI’s share of Microsoft’s sales of its models is in both OpenAI’s revenue and Azure’s; we do not adjust for it. Oracle’s figure is all of its cloud infrastructure revenue, not only AI, and appears only in the sum.
Software. Menlo’s $77.3B of applications less the $40.0B that is the three labs’ own, plus its $99.5B of infrastructure less the $82.7B of the three labs’ other revenue ($122.7B less $40.0B): $54.1B. Menlo’s categories do not sum exactly to its totals; we use the totals. We keep 65% (50% and 75% in the low and high cases), raise it 10% from September to December, and grow it 1.7 times in 2027 (1.4 and 2.2).
Ads. AI’s part is 80% of Meta’s ad revenue above 2023’s grown at 11% a year, and 75% of Google’s above 2023’s grown at 7.5%, as in pack 011. Meta’s 2026 is nine months reported plus the fourth quarter at the middle of its guidance. Google’s is three quarters reported plus a fourth with Search up 11%, YouTube 9% and Network 1%, our estimate. In 2027 Meta’s ad revenue grows 18% (12% and 24%) and Google’s 11% (8% and 14%).
Cases. The low and high cases move every assumption the same way at once, so they are wider than a range in which the layers vary independently. The no-AI trends are held at their central values in all three; their effect is given under “What would move it”.
Against earlier packs. Packs 011 and 013 were written before Alphabet, Microsoft and Amazon reported the third quarter. With those quarters in, the same method gives calendar-2026 AI revenue of $41.5B at Azure (it was $39.4B), $35.5B at AWS ($31.0B), $45.4B at Google Cloud ($38.0B) and $26.8B in Google’s ads ($29.5B). Pack 013 took the labs’ share of AWS’s AI revenue as 50% for its stress cases; the arithmetic above suggests about a third for AWS and Google Cloud together. Neither pack’s conclusions are re-run here.